A little while ago Aletta and I appeared in a webinar for peers and I was asked about my experience working with her. One of the questions was related to difficult moments in the translation and publication process. I can tell you that, luckily, there weren’t that many. The hardest moment didn’t actually occur until after I had finished translating the book, which is an excellent point to continue my story at. I pick things up where I left off over a year ago, as if I have just written Three pairs of eyes.
The translating was done, the proofreaders had given the necessary recommendations and Aletta had looked over my shoulder with each translation. On top of this, Tryntsje, the publisher, had gone through each individual part. The manuscript was ready for the next phase. I assumed that this final reading round would transpire more or less the same as all the previous rounds, so I was not expecting anything in particular. Oh dear, I could not have been more wrong.
My manuscript was first scrutinized by a corrector. This corrector was extremely serious about her job and did a lot more than what was expected of her. You should know that a corrector looks for spelling mistakes and linguistic errors, corrects clunky sentences, and checks whether the list of contents is complete, the chapters have the right headings and whether all images are in their right location. However, my corrector was overzealous. I could picture her holding a red pen, hair in a tight bun, reading glasses on the tip of her nose, constantly shaking her head and tutting disapprovingly. She was draconic, unforgiving and merciless. She amended quotes, changed tenses and introduced literal interpretations of the text.
I had had my work scrutinized before and therefore was used to this. I have learned not to take criticism of my work personally. In the end it is about rendering a product that is well received. Differences in interpretations and personal preference are part of the game and even the best translator is not immune from making a mistake. However, the sheer number of amendments and the determination she showed in this task, threw me for a loop. I not only felt vulnerable and despondent, but my self-confidence had taken a knock. When I think back to that feeling of discomfort that took hold of me, I feel slightly anxious again. After Aletta and I had made our discontent known to Tryntsje, the corrector was replaced by the publishing house’s inhouse-editor.
This man clearly was more experienced and had, as it would appear, more professional know-how and a better feel for the text. Even so, it still was not clear to me how much weight I should give his amendments. Could I defend my translation? Should I defend my translation? And who’s responsibility was it in the end? Mine or Aletta’s? Aletta and I had never discussed how to deal with an energetic whirlwind who was brimming with confidence and had a strong belief in their own recommendations. Consequently, I did not know how to react and did not know what was expected of me. After initially being overwhelmed by it all, Aletta told me to stand up for myself. And she was right. Every translated word originated inside my head and had been well thought-out before writing them down. I must not forget this. Moreover, I had noticed a few inaccuracies and mistakes in the amendments of this highly-experienced in-house editor, which made me realize that no one is infallible. This last phase of the translation process taught me the importance of defending your translation choices and believing in yourself. After all, self-confidence and self-belief go hand in hand.
After this experience the rest of the process continued without any further incidents. It was predominantly about dotting the i’s and crossing the t’s: correct rendering of Frisian place names, index, bibliography, end notes. Everything had to be in order. The cover and title had to appeal to the Dutch market and needed to be altered. I was asked to give my input, which was taken into consideration by the publisher. In the meantime, we had reached March 2019. We were a little bit behind schedule, but the book would be published before dodenherdenking, the Dutch Remembrance Day, on the 4th of May. Coincidentally, in March, I attended a seminar at the London Book Fair, where prominent translators advocated for more recognition of their work. Translators live mostly in the shadow of the authors and are hardly known by the general public, with a few exceptions. ‘This must change’, the speakers at that seminar stated. This change should begin with the translator asking if their name could be printed on the front cover of the book, instead of it appearing on the third or fourth page as it usually does. This question needs to be asked to everyone who can influence the answer: publishers, agents, authors. The entire book world needs to wake up and be alerted to the fact that translations do not create themselves. To produce a translation you require expertise, writing skills, endurance, creativity, cultural awareness, linguistic knowledge, empathy, stress resistance, accuracy, autonomy, analytical insight and discipline. Aletta did not mind my request. In fact, being a translator herself she sympathized, so I asked Tryntsje. Her answer was negative, this is not common practice. I was however pleased with the compromise: my name and short bio would appear on the back cover. In any case, it was important that I had asked the question.
At the beginning of May I was at the book launch in the Dutch province of Friesland and was given the opportunity to speak to the public. Tryntsje referred to Het tweede schot as een kloek boek. Which translates to something along the lines of ‘a courageous book’. It had a nice ring to it and her words made me smile. The days surrounding the book launch were special. Aletta and I were interviewed for a local radio station and we walked in a silent procession to Joop’s grave. Uncle Joop was central to my visit and I felt honoured that I was instrumental in bringing him a little bit closer to the residents of Friesland.
If you are interested in reading my first book translation, please click here. For the original edition, please click here.












